Your Local 

Real Estate Expert

Find your dream home with our powerful property search tool!

Nancy Phander

Send a message
Nancy 2026 Headshot Good

A little bit about me...

I’m Nancy Phander with Coldwell Banker Flanagan Realty, and I’ve proudly helped buyers and sellers navigate the Toms River and Jersey Shore real estate market for over seven years. Having grown up in Old Bridge and made Toms River my home for more than 25 years, I bring deep local knowledge and a genuine understanding of the communities I serve. Real estate is personal to me because every move represents a major life decision, and I treat it with the care and attention it deserves.

With over seven years at Coldwell Banker Flanagan Realty and multiple Circle of Excellence awards, I’ve built my business on results, consistency, and trust. I work with a wide range of clients, from first-time homebuyers to those buying and selling in adult communities, as well as homeowners navigating probate and estate-related sales. As a Senior Real Estate Specialist, I am trained to guide mature clients and their families through complex transitions with patience, clarity, and respect.

What sets me apart is my approach. I believe in honest communication, realistic pricing, and strong negotiation without pressure or shortcuts. My clients are informed at every stage so they can make confident decisions. I am accessible, responsive, and hands-on from the first conversation through closing and beyond.

I’m backed by Coldwell Banker Flanagan Realty, a company that has served the Jersey Shore and Ocean County area for over 40 years. This provides my clients with powerful marketing, strong market data, and the support of a trusted local brokerage with deep community ties. Combined with my experience and personal commitment, it creates a smooth process and strong results.

At the core of my business are professionalism, integrity, and genuine care. Whether you are buying your first home, selling in an adult community, managing a probate property, or planning your next chapter, my goal is to guide you with clarity, confidence, and results you can feel good about.

Discover hidden local gems

Communities

View all

In the Words of my Clients

Success Stories

rb 2
"Nancy was my Veterans United realtor, and she was great. She got a read on my anxiety early, and handled my situation like a true professional."
"I had a pleasure working with nancy , hassel, free and no stress on selling my home!"
"Loved working with Nancy! I have known Nancy for years and knew when it was time to sell my condo and buy a house the experience would be stressful. She was always available to help my husband and I navigate both the selling and buying. She really
"I had a particularly unique situation on a piece of property that I had owned. Nancy was able to overcome the many obstacles and was able sell my land. She is very persistent and determined. Thank you!"

Is it a good time to sell?

How Much is your home really worth?

Let me provide you with a personalized, in-person valuation report. You'll receive an accurate, detailed analysis of your property's value, including insights into market trends and potential opportunities for improvement.

Get your home value

My

Exclusive Listings

View all

Ready to take

The next step?

Not sure if now's the right time to buy or sell? Need a reliable contractor? I would love to get to know more about you and your needs!